Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Peer Visits -- the Duke University Way

I attended a writing conference last week and one of the sessions I attended was on peer assessments. The presenter of the peer assessment session was Denise Comer, Writing Program Administrator, from Duke University. She shared her peer assessment form with us, and I thought it was neat. I modified the form slightly so that it now says Rhodes State College (hint, hint—I’m getting it ready for future use!).

If you’re interested, save--then open after saving--so you can print out the attached form and have it handy, while I explain the peer assessment process they use at Duke University……… At Duke, the observer and instructor have a pre-visit meeting, to which the instructor fills in the first two boxes on the form. Next, the instructor and observer chat about the course – the particular class to be visited and what the instructor wishes to focus on for the visit. This is also a time for reciprocity as the observer can share what is of current concern for him/her in his/her class, program, etc.

After the class visit, the pair meets to discuss the visit and then the instructor fills out the next three boxes on the form. There are only six total boxes which need filling out and instructor is filling out five of them. Interesting, right? After completing the form, except for the last box, the instructor sends the form to the observer. And, finally, the last box is filled out by the observer to say what s/he has learned through the visit. (my highlight)

This process seems to foreground the observee more than usual. The observee says what s/he would like the visit to be focused on; the observee fills out almost the entire peer assessment form; and finally, in the last box, the observer also says what s/he learned from the visit. The approach seems very reflective and focused on meeting the needs of both the observer and the instructor. It looks less like assessment and more like a peer activity from which each benefits. The process and emphasis on reflection is interesting to me. Anyhow, here’s a copy for your perusal. I am posting this information here because the process seems as much like professional development as it does peer assessment.

No comments: